Top Ten Corporate Awards Mistakes (And How to Avoid Them)
Corporate awards are a tangible way to recognize achievements, reinforce company values, and motivate employees. When done well, awards programs leave a lasting impression. When rushed or poorly planned, however, they can feel generic, awkward, or even disappointing.
To help you plan a successful and meaningful recognition program, here are the top 10 corporate awards mistakes and how to avoid them.
Waiting Too Long to Start Planning
One of the most common mistakes is underestimating how long award planning takes. Between design, personalization, proofing, and production, awards require lead time, especially during busy seasons like year-end celebrations or annual meetings.
How to avoid it: Start planning early and confirm timelines with your awards provider to ensure everything arrives on schedule.
Not Defining the Purpose of the Award
Awards without a clear goal often feel disconnected or confusing. Is the award recognizing performance, years of service, leadership, or innovation?
How to avoid it: Define what each award represents and ensure it aligns with your company's values and the behavior you want to encourage.
Choosing Generic or Forgettable Awards
Generic awards can diminish the impact of recognition. If the award feels like an afterthought, recipients may feel the same way.
How to avoid it: Choose awards that reflect the significance of the achievement. Custom engraving, unique designs, and thoughtful materials add meaning and memorability.
Ignoring the Recipient Audience
Not all teams or roles value the same type of recognition. A sales award may look different from a leadership or service milestone award.
How to avoid it: Consider who the recipients are and what type of award best reflects their accomplishments. Tailoring the style or material makes recognition more personal.
Prioritizing Cost Over Quality
While budgets matter, low-quality awards can unintentionally send the wrong message. Flimsy materials or poor craftsmanship can undermine the achievement being honored.
How to avoid it: Balance budget considerations with quality. Well-crafted awards made from durable materials like acrylic, metal, or wood create lasting keepsakes that recipients are proud to display.
Mismatching the Award to the Achievement
A significant milestone deserves more than a simple plaque, while smaller recognitions may not need elaborate designs.
How to avoid it: Match the award's size, style, and materials to the accomplishment's importance. Tiered award programs clearly distinguish levels of achievement.
Overcomplicating the Design
Awards overloaded with text, logos, and design elements can look cluttered and difficult to read.
How to avoid it: Keep designs clean and focused. Highlight the recipient's name, achievement, and date with simple, elegant typography and thoughtful spacing.
Overlooking Presentation and Packaging
How an award is presented matters just as much as the award itself. Poor presentation can lessen the moment.
How to avoid it: Invest in proper presentation: quality boxes, stands, or formal award moments during meetings or ceremonies help elevate the experience.
Not Double-Checking Names and Details
Misspelled names or incorrect dates can turn a proud moment into an embarrassing one.
How to avoid it: Always proofread engraving details carefully. Build time into your schedule for review and approval before final production.
Ordering Too Late for Customization
Custom awards take time to design and produce. Waiting too long limits options and increases stress.
How to avoid it: Place orders early to allow for customization, revisions, and shipping, especially during peak award seasons.
Work With Woltman Trophies & Awards
Corporate awards should celebrate success, strengthen culture, and make recipients feel truly valued. By avoiding these common mistakes and planning with intention, you can create awards that leave a lasting impression and reflect the excellence they're meant to honor.
At Woltman Trophies & Awards, we help organizations design and produce high-quality, customized awards that match the moment.
With the proper planning and attention to detail, your corporate recognition program can be something employees look forward to year after year.
Check out our
design options, and
contact us today to get started!
Don't see exactly what you are looking for?
To explore our Master Catalog with thousands of options
